Original Posting At https://revbrentwhite.com/2017/10/19/are-people-in-hell-repentant/
I’m currently teaching a Bible study on the parables of Jesus in the sanctuary on Sunday mornings. A few weeks ago, we looked at the Parable of the Rich Man and Lazarus from Luke 16:19-31.
Recently some Bible scholars and theologians have rejected the depiction of hell in this parable. The parable isn’t about hell, they say. Jesus was merely adapting a well-known (at the time) Jewish folk tale to make a theological point about something other than perdition.
That may be true for all I know, but that doesn’t mean that Jesus’ words about hell aren’t truthful.
After all, Jesus didn’t tell us the Parable of the Good Samaritan in order to describe the highway connecting Jerusalem with Jericho, but the road that he describes certainly existed! With its twists and turns, it afforded many hiding places for brigands to rob passersby, as they do in the parable. Even though the highway isn’t the point of the parable, the setting is a real place, and Jesus describes it accurately.
My point is, I believe we can learn a lot about hell from this parable.
In my Bible study, we discussed whether the rich man was truly repentant. After all, instead of begging forgiveness of Lazarus, the poor beggar whom the rich man mistreated throughout his life, he instead wants him to leave his place of comfort to fetch him water—through the flames—and warn his brothers of their fate. Even in hell, he continues to treat Lazarus with condescension or contempt, just as he did in the world.
But there’s another clue that the rich man remained unrepentant, as Clay Jones points out in a chapter called “How Can Eternal Punishment Be Fair” in his recent book Why Does God Allow Evil?
Further, the rich man’s suggestion that his brothers needed to be warned betrays a lack of repentance because it implies that he ended up in hell because God didn’t provide him with sufficient warning. Finally, the rich man disagreed with Abraham’s assertions hat the Law of Moses was sufficient evidence to lead his brothers into repentance. As R.C. Trench says, the rich man’s “contempt of God’s word,” which he showed on earth, follows him “beyond the grave.” Ironically, Lazarus was the name of a man who did come back from the dead [See John 11], and the chief priests responded to this resurrection by trying to kill both Jesus and the resurrected Lazarus (John 12:9-10)!
Why is this important? One of the biggest fears that we Christians have about hell is that people who go there will realize immediately that they were wrong, will want to repent, but will be unable. In at least a couple of his apologetic works, The Problem of Pain and The Great Divorce, C.S. Lewis argues against this idea, saying that the doors of hell are “locked from the inside.” In other words, the people who are in hell, in some twisted way, will want to be there—at least more than the alternative, which involves humbling themselves before their Creator and repenting.
I’ve always hoped that Lewis was right. And whatever the case, I have no doubt that God will be perfectly fair. But until I read Dr. Jones’s book I had never considered the biblical evidence for Lewis’s point of view.
1. Clay Jones, Why Does God Allow Evil? (Eugene, OR: Harvest House, 2017), 100.